AdobeStock 46956935

Best Colleges & Uni­ver­si­ties in the Midwest Top Consensus Ranked Schools in the Midwest

Managing Editor
B.A.
Carrie Sealey-Morris has covered bootcamps, careers, and higher education for College Consensus since 2017. Carrie is a graduate of the University of New Mexico where she earned a B.A. in American Studies. 
Founder/Senior Editor
B.A., M.Div.
Jeremy Alder has spent over a decade researching and writing about higher education to provided students with the information they need to achieve their goals. He has significant personal experience with career transitions, working as a freelance writer and editor, non-profit director, community organizer, preacher, teacher, retail manager, and carpenter prior to founding College Consensus. Homeschooled from the second grade, Jeremy is a graduate of the University of Texas at Austin (B.A., Philosophy) and Duke University Divinity School (M.Div.). He currently lives in North Carolina with his wife, five kids, and a Labradoodle named Hank.

Bringing the College Consensus method to the Best Colleges and Universities in the Midwest means giving students a fully rounded, unbiased perspective on what those in the know have to say about their higher education options. With a wide range of published rankings and student reviews out there, College Consensus brings together the most trustworthy data to make an aggregate ranking. That provides the fullest picture available for Midwestern students and future students.

Just like in entertainment and politics, it seems like the East Coast and the West Coast dominate everyone’s attention when it comes to higher education. But the Midwest has some of the highest-ranked, most trusted, and most-loved universities in the nation. The Best Colleges and Universities in the Midwest highlights those sites of excellence. The Midwest’s best universities educate and train the region’s professionals and workers, from teachers to police officers to accountants. These are the institutions that make the Midwest work.

How Do We Rank the Best Colleges in the Midwest?

College Consensus rankings combine the results of the most respected college ranking systems with the averaged ratings of thousands of real student reviews from around the web to create a unique college meta-ranking of all the Best Colleges in the United States. This approach offers a comprehensive and holistic perspective missing from other college rankings. Visit our about page for information on which rankings and review sites were included in this year’s consensus rankings.

The Best Colleges & Universities in the Midwest category is limited to schools in IA, IL, IN, KS, MI, MN, MO, ND, NE, OH, SD, and WI.

What’s Different About the College Consensus Ranking?

College Consensus puts the realities of college rankings and reviews front and center. Every ranking has its own methodology and bias, but putting them all together and including the perspective of students gives College Consensus a birds-eye view of the landscape. That wider perspective offers prospective students a more holistic college ranking that takes in all of what’s known and thought about the Midwest’s colleges and universities.

The Consensus Best Colleges and Universities in the Midwest are listed in descending order by their Consensus score.

1

University of Notre Dame
Notre Dame, IN

89.8
College Consensus
87.6
Student Consensus
91.9
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

2

Washington University in St Louis
Saint Louis, MO

88.7
College Consensus
85.3
Student Consensus
92.1
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

3

University of Chicago
Chicago, IL

88.4
College Consensus
83.4
Student Consensus
93.4
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

4

University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
Ann Arbor, MI

88.4
College Consensus
83.6
Student Consensus
93.2
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

5

Northwestern University
Evanston, IL

88.3
College Consensus
81
Student Consensus
95.6
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

6

University of Wisconsin-Madison
Madison, WI

85
College Consensus
84.8
Student Consensus
85.2
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

7

University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
Champaign, IL

84.9
College Consensus
81.3
Student Consensus
88.6
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

8

Carleton College
Northfield, MN

83.7
College Consensus
85.5
Student Consensus
81.9
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

9

Goshen College
Goshen, IN

83
College Consensus
81.1
Student Consensus
84.9
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

10

University of Northern Iowa
Cedar Falls, IA

82.1
College Consensus
79.5
Student Consensus
84.7
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

11

Simpson College
Indianola, IA

81.2
College Consensus
73.4
Student Consensus
89
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

12

Purdue University-Main Campus
West Lafayette, IN

80.8
College Consensus
82.6
Student Consensus
78.9
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

13

College of the Ozarks
Point Lookout, MO

80.4
College Consensus
76.2
Student Consensus
84.7
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

14

Grinnell College
Grinnell, IA

78.9
College Consensus
81.9
Student Consensus
75.9
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

15

Illinois Wesleyan University
Bloomington, IL

78.8
College Consensus
77.1
Student Consensus
80.4
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

16

Macalester College
Saint Paul, MN

77.8
College Consensus
85.3
Student Consensus
70.2
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

17

University of Minnesota-Twin Cities
Minneapolis, MN

77.4
College Consensus
79
Student Consensus
75.8
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

18

Taylor University
Upland, IN

77.3
College Consensus
80.7
Student Consensus
73.9
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

19

Winona State University
Winona, MN

77
College Consensus
78.9
Student Consensus
75.2
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

20

Milwaukee School of Engineering
Milwaukee, WI

77
College Consensus
77.2
Student Consensus
76.8
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

21

Michigan State University
East Lansing, MI

75.5
College Consensus
82.6
Student Consensus
68.4
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

22

Kenyon College
Gambier, OH

75.3
College Consensus
78.8
Student Consensus
71.7
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

23

DePauw University
Greencastle, IN

74.8
College Consensus
82.5
Student Consensus
67.1
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

24

Augustana University
Sioux Falls, SD

74.8
College Consensus
87.9
Student Consensus
61.7
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

25

Denison University
Granville, OH

74.6
College Consensus
81.8
Student Consensus
67.5
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

26

Truman State University
Kirksville, MO

74.2
College Consensus
79.3
Student Consensus
69.1
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

27

University of Illinois Chicago
Chicago, IL

73.7
College Consensus
74
Student Consensus
73.3
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

28

Cedarville University
Cedarville, OH

73.4
College Consensus
84.1
Student Consensus
62.8
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

29

John Carroll University
University Heights, OH

73
College Consensus
80.5
Student Consensus
65.4
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

30

Ohio State University-Main Campus
Columbus, OH

72.8
College Consensus
82
Student Consensus
63.6
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

31

Indiana University-Bloomington
Bloomington, IN

72.6
College Consensus
81.8
Student Consensus
63.4
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

32

Iowa State University
Ames, IA

72
College Consensus
83.1
Student Consensus
60.8
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

33

Oberlin College
Oberlin, OH

71.9
College Consensus
81.4
Student Consensus
62.4
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

34

Kettering University
Flint, MI

71.5
College Consensus
74.3
Student Consensus
68.8
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

35

Case Western Reserve University
Cleveland, OH

71.3
College Consensus
80.6
Student Consensus
62.1
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

36

St Olaf College
Northfield, MN

71.1
College Consensus
73.4
Student Consensus
68.8
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

37

Marietta College
Marietta, OH

70.8
College Consensus
75.9
Student Consensus
65.7
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

38

Marquette University
Milwaukee, WI

70.5
College Consensus
79.4
Student Consensus
61.7
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

39

Ohio Northern University
Ada, OH

70.5
College Consensus
73.6
Student Consensus
67.3
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

40

Beloit College
Beloit, WI

70.4
College Consensus
75.7
Student Consensus
65.2
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

41

Hamline University
Saint Paul, MN

69.8
College Consensus
71
Student Consensus
68.7
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

42

Calvin University
Grand Rapids, MI

69.5
College Consensus
79.1
Student Consensus
59.8
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

43

Elmhurst University
Elmhurst, IL

67.9
College Consensus
81.7
Student Consensus
54
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

44

Saint Mary’s College
Notre Dame, IN

67.6
College Consensus
75.5
Student Consensus
59.8
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

45

Wheaton College
Wheaton, IL

67.2
College Consensus
76.9
Student Consensus
57.5
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

46

College of Saint Benedict
Saint Joseph, MN

67.2
College Consensus
79.2
Student Consensus
55.2
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

47

University of Iowa
Iowa City, IA

67
College Consensus
82.5
Student Consensus
51.6
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

48

Lawrence University
Appleton, WI

67
College Consensus
74.4
Student Consensus
59.5
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

49

Illinois Institute of Technology
Chicago, IL

66.9
College Consensus
76.1
Student Consensus
57.7
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

50

University of Nebraska at Kearney
Kearney, NE

66.7
College Consensus
75.7
Student Consensus
57.7
Publisher Consensus
Last Accessed: March, 2023

What are the Best Parts of Going to College in the Midwest?

The best colleges in the Midwest provide good value for your money. Many Midwest universities offer a lower cost of living, higher quality of life, better scholarships, and lower tuition than universities in other regions.

The states with the highest cost of living are generally those on the West Coast or in the Northeast. In the Midwest, the cost of living is generally lower. This means lower prices for everything from rent to groceries to fast food. Going to school in an area of the country where the cost of living is lower makes it easier for students to afford tuition and other school-related expenses.

Midwestern schools often offer a higher quality of life as well. The Midwest offers a sense of community, with many resources, such as sporting events, concerts, libraries, and fitness centers within easy walking distance from the college. Many Midwestern universities are located near large cities so students can walk to the city center for even more recreational opportunities.

The best Midwest universities offer a variety of scholarships to help students who need financial aid. These scholarships may be limited to students in certain programs or with certain ethnic backgrounds, or they may be available to anyone. Each scholarship has its own requirements. By taking advantage of scholarships, you can often attend college for much less than the full tuition cost.

Should I Go to College in the Midwest if I’m Not From There?

There are pros and cons to attending Midwest colleges if you are not from the Midwest. The biggest con is probably out-of-state tuition. If you are attending a public college or university, the school likely charges a significantly higher tuition rate to out-of-state students. This is because the school receives funding from the state to help offset the tuition of in-state students.

Another con is that you may feel isolated if you attend a school in a different region of the country than where you are from. You’ll be far away from your family and friends, leaving you feeling alone and maybe a bit homesick. It may be difficult to go home for visits if you are far away, so you’ll want to try to make new friends quickly so you won’t feel so lonely.

On the plus side, being away from home can help get you out of your comfort zone. You’ll meet a lot of new people and learn to get along with those who are different from yourself. You’ll learn important lessons about life, diversity, and empathy.

In addition, if you have more colleges to choose from, you’ll have an easier time finding one that offers your major. This may not be an issue if you are majoring in business, but if you want to study agriculture or aerospace engineering, you’ll find that there are fewer options available.

Are Colleges in the Midwest Diverse?

Universities in the Midwest vary widely in their level of diversity. Mount Mary University, Alverno College, Augsburg University, and Calumet College of St. Joseph are among the most diverse colleges in the Midwest, while Dordt University, Shawnee State University, Cedarville University, and the University of Wisconsin-Platteville are among the least diverse.

Many of the best universities in the Midwest make some sort of effort to attract students from different ethnic and regional backgrounds. They do this by offering scholarships based on ethnic background or offering special tuition rates to foreign students.

Diversity at the best Midwest colleges is important because it increases creativity and innovation, improves performance and productivity, and encourages personal growth.

Having many different people working together who have different backgrounds increases the chances that someone will have an idea that sparks innovation. If everyone at the top Midwest colleges has the same ideas, no one will ever come up with newer and better ways of doing things. Diversity increases the number of inputs into the creative process and helps increase innovation as a result.

When people with different backgrounds work together, it improves the productivity of the whole team because those who are better at different things can focus on those tasks. Everyone does what they are best at, so the group performs better overall.

Diversity also encourages personal growth by forcing us to learn to get along with those who are different from ourselves. As we learn about new cultures and languages, we learn to interact with those who are different from us and we become better people in the process.

Related:

us map

Best MBA Programs in the Midwest


Top Consensus Ranked MBAs in the Midwest

skiing college winter break

25 Best Colleges for Skiing & Snow­board­ing


Top Consensus Ranked Schools for Winter Fun

wellesley waban

25 Best Outdoor Colleges on Rivers and Lakes


Top Consensus Ranked Schools on the Water

Ready to start your journey?

Get a personalized list of degree programs that fit your needs.